
New proposals to tackle Britain’s growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) present a range of opportunities for bakeries, according to industry organisations.
Almost a million young people in the UK currently fall into the NEET category. To address this issue, the government yesterday (17 November) published a report by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn entitled ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: A New Settlement for the Next Generation’.
Among its key proposals were to provide financial incentives to businesses employing youngsters, to lower National Insurance contributions, and to reform apprenticeships with the aim of doubling participation over the next decade.
Craft Bakers Association chief executive Karen Dear welcomed the report, noting the bakery sector has long faced challenges in attracting and retaining the next generation of skilled bakers. However, she said there were some fundamental questions that need answering before being confident the proposals will deliver meaningful benefits.
“Firstly, will bakery businesses qualify for the proposed employer National Insurance (NI) reductions for young people aged 21–24?” asked Dear. “Many operate across manufacturing, retail and hospitality, and it is essential they are not excluded simply because of how their businesses are classified.”
“Secondly, will the proposed £3,000 employment incentive genuinely offset the costs of recruiting, supervising and training someone with little or no previous work experience?”
Dear said it was difficult to reconcile the ambition to encourage businesses to employ more young people with an operating environment in which the cost of employing people and running a bakery continues to rise. “Financial incentives are welcome, but a one-off payment will do little to encourage long-term recruitment if businesses are struggling to maintain profitability, protect existing jobs or invest in their future,” she added.
There is also the question of where these young employees would receive their bakery education.
The government needs to ensure that pre-apprenticeship programmes provide a genuine pathway into recognised bakery apprenticeships and qualifications, rather than becoming another short-term initiative with limited long-term outcomes, highlighted Dear.
“It is worth remembering that we have been here before,” she said. “The Youth Opportunities Programme was introduced in 1978, followed by the Youth Training Scheme in 1983, which ended in 1990. More recently, we have seen initiatives such as Kickstart.
“The important question is what lessons have been learned from these previous initiatives and what will make this latest approach more successful.”

Terry Fennell, CEO at food & drink specialist awarding organisation FDQ, gave a more optimistic outlook of the benefits to bakery education offered by the Milburn Review, which he said “represents the most significant reform of apprenticeships for a generation”.
The report helps address the “worryingly decline” in participation among young people, particularly at Level 2, where starts for 16- to 21-year-olds have fallen by 73% over the past decade, noted Fennell. “At its heart is a clear ambition to restore apprenticeships to their original purpose: providing young people with a pathway into skilled employment while helping employers build a sustainable workforce,” he added.
In addition to the potential offsetting of recruitment and onboarding costs through financial incentives for employers and NI contribution cuts, there is a proposal of a Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) to be established across England by 2029.
“Many bakery employers tell us they struggle to know where to advertise vacancies, how to attract suitable applicants and which organisations can help,” commented Fennell. “A locally based YOS could provide a much-needed single point of access for both employers and young people, helping bakeries connect with prospective apprentices more effectively.”
Fennell also noted that the Milburn Review appears to have support across government, including the Treasury, which will be critical if these recommendations are to move from aspiration to implementation.
“The real test will be whether the reforms are delivered at pace and in a way that makes recruitment simpler, more affordable and more attractive for bakery employers. If that happens, the sector stands to benefit significantly from a stronger pipeline of skilled young people entering the workforce,” he asserted.



















No comments yet